Important! June 12th, 2024 Webinar Attendees, please click here to complete our Survey or Verification Request Form.

Click Here

You must login to access this content

Picture of Login

Login

Access Your Alta Pro RPG Account

Login so you can:

1 Hour

Essential Business Skills for Busy Lawyers Part 1 – Communicate Like A Pro

1 Hour

Creating an Attorney Compensation Plan That Will Build Firm Culture and Attract Top Talent

1 Hour

Cybersecurity for Attorneys: Employing Competent and Reasonable Safeguards

Arbitration Clauses

Share

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Executive Summary

There are good reasons to include an arbitration clause in your engagement agreement. But there are dangers as well – especially if you ask your client to agree to arbitrate anything other than a fee dispute. Weigh the benefits and risks before asking your clients to sign one.

Special Scrutiny for Lawyers

Arbitration clauses are widespread in consumer, business and employment contracts as a way to resolve disputes quickly and inexpensively. Courts have generally upheld these clauses if it can be proven that (a) both parties knowingly agreed, and (b) arbitration provides a neutral forum to resolve disputes.

Arbitration clauses are becoming more common in law practices as well. But the fiduciary nature of the attorney-client relationship creates a special situation that requires special scrutiny.

Alta Pro Practice Pointers

  1. Arbitration is safer than suing your client for unpaid fees. More than half of all fee suits prompt a counterclaim for legal malpractice, according to insurance industry sources. Given such exposure, it makes sense to explore other options like arbitration.
  2. Know your state’s rules. Most states allow lawyers to include arbitration clauses in engagement agreements. But there are important caveats. North Carolina, for example, says you can never ask your client to agree not to report you to the State Bar, and you must inform them that the bar has its own fee dispute program. What does your state say? Do some research to find out.
  3. Follow the ABA recommendations. In 2011, the ABA passed a comprehensive Model Rule for Fee Arbitration. read it here.
  4. Tailor your clause. Disclose the types of claims it is intended to cover: fee disputes and (possibly) malpractice claims. But be careful: some states require clients to get separate, independent counsel before signing an agreement to arbitrate malpractice claims. And the agreement might jeopardize your liability coverage if you don’t get written approval from your carrier in advance. Consider limiting the agreement to fee disputes and collection controversies.
  5. Tell clients what they need to know. Explain that arbitration is generally quicker, cheaper and less formal than litigation – but, depending on your state, the initial costs might be higher. Let them know they’re waiving their right to a trial, appeal and the rules of civil procedure.
  6. Give them the opportunity to get a second opinion. Advise them of their right to have the engagement agreement reviewed by another lawyer not associated with your firm. It may be awkward to begin the relationship by recommending this, much less asking your client to waive certain rights and remedies. Do it anyway. Some firms try to gloss over this with a single sentence saying “disputes will be resolved by binding arbitration subject to [a specific arbitration standard].” This is unwise. The more detailed your arbitration clause, the more likely it will be enforced.
  7. Have the client sign the arbitration agreement. Even better, make it a separate document. Generally, judges support arbitration agreements when it’s reasonable to do so. Was the client reasonably informed of the agreement’s impact? Did the firm try in good faith to work things out? Are the underlying facts egregious? Arbitration clauses won’t be enforced amid allegations of lawyer misconduct.

The Bottom Line: Before using an arbitration agreement, research your state rules. And remember: your ethical duty is to your client, not to making your life easier.

What’s Next?


Have a question about arbitration clauses? Ask the Risk Pro!


Looking for pointers on avoiding billing and fee disputes? Click here!

Heads up!
This information is intended for informative purposes for members of Alta Pro Lawyers Risk Purchasing Group. It is not intended as legal advice. Lawyers should always refer to local and state rules and statutes for applicable standards and rules. These guidelines are designed to help lawyers avoid professional liability claims and are not intended for any other purpose. No legal or fiduciary relationship is intended to be created by receipt of this material.

Share

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Related Posts on Altaprorpg.com!

About the Editorial Staff

In an age of consolidation where increasingly impersonal transactions have made customer service an oxymoron, we bring together independent agents, insurance companies, and other industry specific service providers to develop and deliver insurance products and risk management solutions that benefit our insurance customers.

Join Our Newsletter

Occasional newsletters and CLE invites

Find Us on Social

Upcoming CLE Webinar: Essential Business Skills for Busy Lawyers Part 2 – Build Your Legal Practice Like a Pro

August 28, 2024 1:00 pm EST
CLE Credit: 1.0 Regular

Colleen L. Byers

Colleen Byers Mediation, LLC

Need Help?

Visit our Frequently Asked Questions page. 

Or email us directly at info@altaprorpg.com

Or submit your issue in the comment form below and we will respond as soon as possible.